Enough with the name of Macedonia!
All these days we see a marathon of the greek government to achieve an agreement between herself and the Forme Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia over the name of this country. Both sides are willing to finish with the issue for different issues. While FYROM wants to be invited to join the NATO and so it has to find a solution in order to avoid a greek veto, Greece wants to close an issue that provoked so many problems to her foreign policy. Even though from both sides many extremistes were declaring that Macedonia is Greek or Macedonia is Macedonian I believe that tha majority of the people in both sides clearly understand that the issue of the name is too trivial to cause such great problems. For Greece this story is like a greek tragedy while after so many years of indifference over the issue she faced a non convinient for her reality after the declaration of Macedonia as an indipendant state - even though all these years before, Greece recognized the Republic of Macedonia within the Yugoslavian Federation. I dont want to present the history of the dispute between the two countries. What is important now at this very moment of negotiation is not the name of FYROM. Greece finally understood that she hasnt a monopoly of the name Macedonia because of the ancient legacy. Nobody who knows history in this planet believes that the inhabitants of FYROM are connected to Alexander's kingdom. What we have to understand is that Macedonia is not something that belongs only to one people. Macedonia is rich of multinational coexistance and culture during the Byzantine and Ottoman era, where Serbians, Slavmacedonians, Bulgarians, Jews, Albanians, Greek and Turks lived together. So the name Macedonia means a lot of things to all of these people. So, FYROM has to accept a solution which of course involve the term Macedonia but with a remark that they are not the only Macedonians in the region. Every people in this planet has the right to self -determination so the Macedonians of FYROM. But this right must not insult other nations in order to co-exist in harmony. As a result in order to become a member of NATO and the EU, FYROM has to renounce any possible territorial claim over her neighbours (Greece and Bulgaria) something which is vital for the stability in the region.
on 19-03-2008 By Giorgos - Corinthian column
- Permalink
-
Share
Dora
Asimina Managlioti
Angelina Bassi
SimonR
Dimi
Ioannis Koutrakos
konstantina
FROGGY
tintin
Alekos
chris
lycanthrope
luca amos
jean-marc.laborie
Sofia Belegrinou
benakiba
Elina
Georgios
ilialap
Comments
I agree with you. Macedonia is a large georgraphic region and no one group should be entitled to monopolise the name to the humiliation of an other. This is why a geographical qualifier should be attached to the official name of FYROM such as the 'Republic of Northern Macedonia' or the 'Republic of Upper Macedonia' to distinguish it from Greek Macedonia (South Macedonia). For there to be a just and viable solution there needs to be a commitment to use this name for all purposes including domestic use. The reason I argue this is because if this not a requirement the two countries will be in this predicament again in 10 years when Greece will accuse FYROM (or whatever its name will be at that point in time) of promoting use of the name 'Republic of Macedonia' again in international and bilaterial communications with other nations. The Greek government has already made concessions when it comes to the name issue (they were vehemently against any name that even mentioned the word 'Macedonia') now I believe FYROM needs to take the necessary steps to secure its Euro-Atlantic prospects.
Republic of Macedonia is the proper name for the country bordering north of the Hellenic Republic.
The Republic of Macedonia does not have any territorial claims over the Greek province of Macedonia, nor does she have the military means to pose a threat to Greece.
Greece should quietly accept what over 100 countries in the world have already recognized. No country has a monopoly over world history. There is also a town of Macedonia here, in Ohio, USA, but nobody is thinking of changing its name out of consideration for ancient history claims.
You forget to mention the Bucharest treaty of 1913, which divided the lands of Ancient Macedonia amongst Greece, Bulgaria and Serbia. The part given to Serbia back then is now the Republic of Macedonia.
You forget to mention the systematic forced assimilation of Slav speaking Macedonians, by being denied to speak their own language and having their names changed to Greek sounding ones.
You forget to mention that before the 1913 treaty which divided Macedonia, Macedonians were the majority people on the whole region of Macedonia, including the region which today is under Greece.
You forget to mention the population trade between Greece and Turkey where 1 million Christians from Turkey were settled in Greek-Macedonia, which is the reason why "Greeks" now form a majority there. These same Christian Turks who have lived on that land for less than a century profess to be the true descendants of Alexander the Great? Yet we are not because we "speak" a Slavic Language? Languages throughout history have been lost and new ones adopted. Sure Slavs settled in the lands of todays Macedonia, but they also settled in parts of Greece and Italy, yet the latter are not considered Slavs because they did not adopt the Slavic language. We ADOPTED the Slavic language; the ancient Macedonians were not wiped off the face of the earth, the Slavs invaded, as did the Romans etc....these people mixed with the native people of that land. We are the descendants of that lineage. There were hardly any Greeks in that land before 1913 except for a pocket in Chalkidiki, the rest of them were forcefully settled there from Turkey.
To say that we are Slavs because we speak a Slavic language is to say that Irish, Welsh and Scottish are English because they speak an adopted English language. Or that Basque people are Spanish because they speak and adopted Spanish language. You see throughout history this has occurred and is still occurring. I’m positive within a century or two, any traces of the Gaelic or Basque languages would have disappeared, yet those people will not become English or Spanish.
So for anyone to say Greeks and not Macedonians are descendants of ancient Macedonians are plain absurd.
The misconceptions that the rest of the world is lead to believe is the result of years of Greek propaganda. The victor always writes history, Greece is more powerful and has more influence in the world, us little people have to fight for what’s right while the victors blatantly spread lies and hate amongst people.
The fact is all that i have stated is true and common sense. Anyone who is actually interested in the issue can do their own research and find this information out. The Greeks will blatantly ignore the 1913 treaty of Bucharest or the Greek population trade from any of their Macedonia history sources.
Oh, and you also forget to mention that the Republic of Macedonia already renounced any possible territorial claims against it's neighbours back in the nineties, when it changed it's flag and constitution to please the Greeks. Territorial aspirations towards its neighbours are renounced in the constitution of the Republic of Macedonia, which makes this whole situation absurd. Greece's claims are absurd, there is a lot more to this than just a name. If anyone is truly interested, then do your own research, the western media will never back stab their Greek brothers and tell u the truth.
Also visit www.florina.org the Macedonian party in Greece. Read some of the stories of human rights abuses against Macedonians and you'll soon realise that the "cradle of civilisation" the "birthplace of Democracy" is responsible for some of the worst human rights abuses of our time and is still carrying them out.
Today, as we enter the 21st century, the Macedonians of Greece continue to be harassed and discriminated by the Greek government, 87 years since Greece took over Aegean Macedonia. The Macedonian language is still not recognized, the Macedonian nationality is still denied, and the Macedonians are still forced to have Greek family names, because having a Macedonian name Greece considers illegal. Human Rights Watch (Denying Ethnic Identity - Macedonians of Greece), Amnesty International, and the European Community have the Greek oppression of the Macedonians well documented, found Greece guilty, and demanded that it recognize the Macedonian language and nation and end its oppression. Despite of it, the Macedonians continue to exist in Greece as majority in the northern half of Aegean Macedonia and as minority in the southern half, and peacefully continue to demand their human rights. Will Greece ever became a democracy?
Let us be who we are and call us by our name MACEDONIA
There is a province called Pirin Macedonia in Bulgaria adjacet to the Republic of Macedonia. Are the Bulgarians crying? No they are not, they were the first country to recognise Macedonia under her constitutional name. You see by putting the word 'Republic' in front of the name, it was clear you were dealing with a country and not a province. The Bulgarians got that, but the Greeks are still trying to figure it out.
This is nonsense, Greece is using its influence on certain weak-minded EU members to help cover up its human rights abuses. That's the beginning and the end of this 'name argument'. The European Union is disgracing itself with this "non-issue". Time to respect the right of a people to call themselves as they are and to name their own country.
One of the worst articles i have ever read. It hilariously contradicts itself with ease.
Macedonians have the universal right to declare as Macedonians. Without exception!
I was, I am and I will always be Macedonian. I don't understand how you can equate nationalism with the basic human right of self identification. My grandparents come from both the Republic of Macedonia and the Macedonian region that is under Greek rule. They all share the same Macedonian identity and they all speak the same language, Macedonian. They all share the same language and identity as millions of other Macedonians spread out around the world. Although my grandmother's village lies in present day Greece, it will forever be Macedonia to me and my family. It's rather disgusting to me that the world turned their backs on the Macedonians and their plight. History is written by the victors, but it is not always the truth. The truth is passed on and never forgotten. I know the Macedonian truth and I will continue to pass it on to my children. I thank my grandparents for never allowing the Greek government and church to break them down and assimilate them. Da ziveje Makedonija i Makedoncite. Razbudetese i bidete jaki! Diasporata ve podrzava!
"Every people in this planet has the right to self -determination so the Macedonians of FYROM. But this right must not insult other nations in order to co-exist in harmony."
According to this principle, I wonder if the Nazis may have been judged wrongly... since they too were also 'insulted' by the self-determination and presence of the Jews as a people?
Is not the renaming of a nation and a nationality an attempt to eliminate its historical and cultural links...a cultural genocide?
I am sorry that my existence and self-determination as a Macedonian insult Greek people in anyway...but in the end...this is their problem, not mine...I will not cease to exist and I will not forgo my human right and dignity to call myself and my country as I choose because of Greek insecurities!
How can one live in harmony when recognition of your fellow man's identity is being trampled on?
Young greeks, grkomani and hellenised minorities. The time ahs come for you to step back and realise what you are doing is the biggest load of bullshit your pathetic government has fed you. It is time you yourselves stopped and thought about what you are doing and that it is useless following what your government is feeding you blindly and without cause.
I am Macedonia. My whole family is Macedonian. I know many, MANY Macedonians from 'Aegean' Macedonia. They were never greek, at any point of their lives and have endured a false greek identity forced upon them.
The name issue is an attempt to cover this up along with the many other attempts at culturral genocide the greeks have committed against the Macedonians over the years.
If you don't believe this, you are brainwashed.
No country has the right to tell another country what to call themselves based on a province. Wake up greeks.
I demand the president of France Mr Sarkozy to openly appologize to all the Macedonians for hummiliating them in public with his statement about how should my country be called. Otherwise Mr Sarkozy might be taken to international court for exercising racial harassment and discrimination and subtile genocid towards entire Macedonian nation.
Second the Mediator Nimitz has to withdraw himself from the mediatorship for breaking the basic human laws of UN, the organization which gave him the mediatorship, with his last proposal.
At the end I want to point to NATO not to allow to be a personal toy of the Greek goverment, because what the Greek goverment is doing now towards us is because it doesn't want to see us in NATO. So NATO if you really want our country inside the organization, and if you want to interfere in this ridiculous dispute, you should work on the real problems between us. That is recognition of the Macedonian minority in Greece and returning the property of Macedonians expeled from Greece during the civil war in 45-48. Nato pls do not be naive to think that if we agree on the name issue the problems between our countries will pass. The real problems would then begin and NATO will blow its head out of troubles.
P.S. If Greek people have problem with their national identification, I don't have that kind of problem. I am Macedonian have no other choice but to be Macedonian.
The War Will Begin Soon Macedonians Living In Greece (Aegean Macedonia) & Bulgaria (Pirin Macedonia) Will Begin A War Of (Pride) (History) (Identity) Along With The Macedonians From The Republic Of Macedonia & The Macedonian Diaspora Around The World Will Fight 2 European Union Members And Will Stop At Nothing To Gain Our Freedom And Get Back Our Lands.Any NATO UN OR US Peace Keepers Get It Our Way And We Will Kill Them And If Europe Wants To Takes Us On We Will Show Them Hell Just Like Our Greatest Warrior Did "Alexander The Great Of Macedonia" We Wont Stop At Nothing If We Have To We Will Destroy Sofia & Burn Athens To The Ground.They Might Have More Weapons & Numbers Than Us But We Have Better Tactics And Know Our Way Around The Whole Balkans.This War Will Be The Bloodiest War Of The 21st Century.We Urge Any Greeks & Bulgarians Who Wish Peace To Fight With Us Agaisnt Them With Us You Will Get Better Treatment & More Rights.The War Will Begin Soon & After More Than 2000 Years Macedonians Will Welcome The Return Of Throne And A New King Will Arise.
To Andrew - the reason why Pirin Macedonia isnt a factor in this dispute is because the Bulgarians do not argue that they are Macedonians - instead they argue that Macedonians (citizens of the Republic of Macedonia) are Bulgarians and that the language is a dialect of Bulgarian. A sizeable number of Macedonians have even taken out Bulgarian citizenship on 'ancestrial grounds'
As for human rights violations, perhaps the Macedonians should take up those with the EU court of Human Rights
Pleas NATo don't make such a precedent for our entrance, how would look the other potential countries that want to enter in NATO when they see how you push us and blackmail us? Maybe they will change their mind when it comes to further enlargement?!?! I don't want anything else but to enter in the organization with dignity and self-respect like every other country that is entering. Because we will all be long-run allies in the organization. And fight against therorism together. Equal basic human rights for all! Nothing less and nothing more I don't ask from you.
Methodius? Are you maybe Greek here for promoting false propaganda here in public? Trying to make us savadges here in public? Because none of the minorities in greece is so self confident and feels so strong to speak such bulshits.
FYROM = Yugoslavs = SOuth Slavs, it's what they are, it's their culture it's their history it's their language.
Everyone that has read or studied ancient Greece and Alexander that Great know that the Ancient Macedonians are of Greek Origin. Modern Greece today is trying to compromise on the name Macedonia with FYROM for example, Northern Macedonia, Nova Macedonia , New Macedonia etc, etc, and FYROM has rejected every name. This battle for the Macedonia name has been going on since the 1950s. Its Time for FYROM to end this game.
Macedonia ..
WAS
IS
& ALWAYS
WILL
BE
GREEK!
..
ALEXANDER THE GREAT WAS A GREEK!!
& NOT A SLAV!!
ZITO H HELLAS.. ZITO H MAKEDONIA!
Enough with the BS of Greece. They have the worst human rights record in Europe yet proclaim the basis of joining the EU and NATO is for good neighbourly relations?
Does that include ethnic & cultural genocide by torturing, assimilating and forcefully expelling hundreds of thousands of ethnic Macedonian's from occupied Aegean (Greek) Macedonia after 1913 only to bring in the descendants of Alexander the Great who apparently are Christian Turks? Can't people see through the Greek governments facade of BS?
Eugene Borza an American Professor actually states the ancient Macedonians were not Greek nor related to the Greeks. The adoption of Greek in the courts of ancient Macedonia means nothing about the ethnicity of the people, just like the fact the Irish, Scottish and Welsh have all lost their Gaelic language does not mean they are all of the sudden ethnically English because they officially speak English.
Slav refers to a linguistic sub-branch of the INdo-European family not an ethnicity!
Have a read you may learn something...
http://macedoniaonline.eu/content/v...
THIS IS FOR THE SERBS......
How do you fell about the lose of the Kosovo province?
Now you know how it is to be a Macedonian, when Macedonia was splite in pieces in 1913.
THIS IS FOR THE GREEKS.......
History always repeates itself, no matter what you do.
Let me put it in simple terms "what goes around, cames around twice as hard".
THIS IS FOR THE BULGARIANS........
Just keep on giving Visas to the Macedonian people.
When the time cames to unite Macedonia you will have more Macedonians in your country to vote for united Macedonia.
THIS IS FOR EVERYONE...........
As you can see these 3 countries that have been bad to the Macedonians will get punishment, whether from NATO, EU and UN or from GOD.
A barking dog never bites.
Greeks you are worst than Serbs!! The whole world was laughing on Serbs looking in the history of 13 century, and you?!?!? what are you doing?!?!? You are looking back in 3000 years before!!!! how mauch is NATO concearned about that history?!?!? You have very lousy theory about this dispute. I cannot imagine what the organization thinks about you now.
One side Journalism from a journalist who was probably bribed is the best way to describe this article.
The right to self declaration is right each and everyone nation has. Macedonia is shown in the bible and not greece, if anything greece should change its name, but wait they already did! prior to 1988 Greek Macedonia as the greeks now call it was referred to in all offical state matters as northern greece so from 1913 to 1988 Northern Greece was its offical name, funny how macedonia should change its name considering that name has been used for over 3,000 years.. and the greeks have only used the name for 20 years and annexed this part of Macedonia 95 years ago.
Greeks cannot claim direct lineage to Alexander the Great as mentioned above by Goste these christian turks from Anatolia who could not even speak greek 100 years ago are new comers to the land while macedonians have remained even after attemps to assimilate them.
Modern greeks are a nation of albanians, slavs, arabs, vlachs, jews and refugess from Asia Minor
Greece has the highest incidence of the J Hapoltype marker (which is common in Arab lands) cause its population is not native to the land they are decedents of Arvanites Albanians from the 15th centurary along with Christians Turks from Asia Minor, Vlachs, slavs and Macedonians who were assimilated to produce this artificial nation.
Also Slavs did arrive in Macedonia and the Balkans but not in the numbers once believed, like most nations Macedonia has been conquered and over run by other tribes nations but Macedonians should not be called Slavic Macedonians but simply Macedonians, the Slavs were not warriors but farmers who assimilated with the native population, The MACEDONIAN POPULATION. No one refers to the Russians as Slavic Russians or Serbs as Slavic Serbs when referring to their ethnicity so why should Macedonians suffer this injustice. modern nations are a mixture of different ancient and modern peoples.
The Former Ottoman Republic of Western Turkey, Greece - FOROWTG is trying to eliminate the macedonians and along with it the truth that Macedonia never belonged to Greece.
Greece is Turkey....
One sided Journalism from a journalist who was probably bribed is the best way to describe this article.
The right to self declaration is right each and everyone nation has. Macedonia is shown in the bible and not greece, if anything greece should change its name, but wait they already did! prior to 1988 Greek Macedonia as the greeks now call it was referred to in all offical state matters as northern greece so from 1913 to 1988 Northern Greece was its offical name, funny how macedonia should change its name considering that name has been used for over 3,000 years.. and the greeks have only used the name for 20 years and annexed this part of Macedonia 95 years ago.
Greeks cannot claim direct lineage to Alexander the Great as mentioned above by Goste these christian turks from Anatolia who could not even speak greek 100 years ago are new comers to the land while macedonians have remained even after attemps to assimilate them.
Modern greeks are a nation of albanians, slavs, arabs, vlachs, jews and refugess from Asia Minor
Greece has the highest incidence of the J Hapoltype marker (which is common in Arab lands) cause its population is not native to the land they are decedents of Arvanites Albanians from the 15th centurary along with Christians Turks from Asia Minor, Vlachs, slavs and Macedonians who were assimilated to produce this artificial nation.
Also Slavs did arrive in Macedonia and the Balkans but not in the numbers once believed, like most nations Macedonia has been conquered and over run by other tribes nations but Macedonians should not be called Slavic Macedonians but simply Macedonians, the Slavs were not warriors but farmers who assimilated with the native population, The MACEDONIAN POPULATION. No one refers to the Russians as Slavic Russians or Serbs as Slavic Serbs when referring to their ethnicity so why should Macedonians suffer this injustice. modern nations are a mixture of different ancient and modern peoples.
The Former Ottoman Republic of Western Turkey, Greece - FOROWTG is trying to eliminate the macedonians and along with it the truth that Macedonia never belonged to Greece.
THIS IS FOR THE TURKS.........
You have been fantastic people for the last 80 yoears.
Your next to be given a veto by Greece over the Cyprus issue, it looks like Greece has lots of power over NATO, it can give vetos when ever it fell like.
AND THIS IS MY OPINION.........
How stupit is Greece barking for a name that does not belong to them or history.
Greece was formed in 1832 as a nation without any pieces of the geographical Macedonia. 176 years later they claim Macedonia as theirs and it goes back 4000 years ago. Now that is stupit and dumb.
to anuska - the world can laugh as much as it wants. At the end of the day Greece has veto power in an organisation that FYROM wants to enter. So Greece is laughing right now because they have the power for make FYROM do what it wants!
MACEDONIA IS WAS AND ALWAYS WILL BE MACEDONIAN
ALEXANDER THE GREAT IS WAS AND ALWAYS WILL BE MACEDONIAN
GREECE IS WAS AND ALWAYS WILL BE GAY
LEONIDAS IS WAS AND ALWAYS WILL BE GAY
TO ANUSKA YOUR A FUCKING DISGRACE TO OUR PEOPLE HOW THE FUCK ARE YOU GONA GET SOMETHING WITHOUT BEING VIOLENT WE'VE BEIN DOING THAT FOR THE PAST 17 YEARS AND WHAT THAY STILL CALL MACEDONIA GREEK.IF A MACEDONIANS GONA LISTEN TO YOU THERE GONA GET FUKED UP BECAUSE UR DUMB WAY OF ACHIEVING SHIT IS PEACE,FUCK PEACE,A GUY HAD A GREEK MACEDONIA FLAG OH HIS PORCHE ONE DAY AND U KNO WOT I DONE I TRASHED HIS PLACE AND PUT HIM IN ACHOMA THATS THE ONLY WAY OUR PEOPLE CAN BE HEARD TO GO BACK TO OUR ANCESTRY THE WAY THE ALEXANDER THE GREAT DONE IT BURNING CITYS AND KILLING EVERYTHING IN HIS WAY
STOP USING A GREEK NAME (METHODIUS) YOU COCK SUCKING BULGAROV BITCH. THINK YOU BULGAROVS ARE TOUGH? START A WAR CUNT AND WE WILL WIPE YOUR WEST BULGARIA OFF THE MAP YOU GAY DREAMING PEDEROV CIGANOV.
GOTSE THE BULGARIAN, GO BACK TO YOUR MOTHERLAND BULGARIA CIGANOV BULGAROV. MACEDONIA HAS A MESSAGE FOR YOU BULGAROVS FROM SKOPJE: "GO AND GET FUCKED, I BELONG TO THE GREEKS".
TO ANUSKA BULGAROVA, YOU TYPE LIKE AN UNEDUCATED WEST BULGARIAN BITCH. HOW BOUT THIS DIE GIPSY SKOPJE!!!!! LOVE MACEDONIA.
There is no macedonian in fyrom,they are all confused bulgarians.If you want to be a Macedonian join the greek macedonia.
DUNDEE UTD, YOU LISTEN TO A DICKHEAD'S (BORZA) WORDS AND IT EVEN PUBLISHED BECAUSE ANTHROPOLOGISTS FOUND HIS ARTICLE TO BE COMPLETELY FALSE YOU IGNORANT BULGAROV CUNT. TREATY OF 1913 IS IRRELEVANT DICKHEAD. YOU KNOW FUCK ALL ABOUT MACEDONIA YOU COCK SUCKING BULGAROV.
MONGOLGAYTURK, WE ARE FUCKING YOU SINCE 1821 CUNT. YOU HATE US BECAUSE WE SLAUGHTERED YOU GAYTURKS ONE BY ONE AND YOU LOVE THE BULGAROVS BECAUSE THEY WERE SUCKING YOUR DICKS. HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.
ONLY THE UNEDUCATED SAY THAT MACEDONIA IS NOT GREEK.
i am a macedonian, and i am a greek - its the same thing. these slav speaking minorities in greece are infact greek, but they have adopted slavic customs and slavic language. if you visit them in greece, you will see they are proud to call themselves greek, however they also speak the local language which is slav. there is no confusion in greece. p.s. how many soldiers in alexander's army where called zoran and goran and zlate or kiro or dolce? the soldiers where all greek with greek names, not slav ones. he even named his horse buchephalus (a greek word)
the complex of all the fyromians is illustrated in youtube when they post scenes from oliver stones alexander..they cut the scene where alexander says 'FOR THE FREEDOM AND GLORY OF GREECE'...It hurts to listen the truth fyromians...
I am also from Macedonia - 30 minutes from the metropolis Thessaloniki. All I have to say to our friends from ex-Yugoslavia.
My name is George and I am Macedonian - who are you?
I am flattered you are dying to be me - but the facts remain you are you and me is me. I will never be Slavised =- because-= I am MACEDONIAN.
The Bulgars need to thump their chests like Tarzan trying to convince the world they are Macedonian...and me, well I find you all very amusing!
It must really suck to be a wannabe.
iF yoy want to read more troubled fyromians and laugh visit maknews....the home of idiots and confused bulgarians.
Macedonia was never Greek's, it was the other way arround, Macedonians conquered Greece, so territory which is at present Greece was occupied and ruled by Macedonians. Macedonians and Ilirians were allies and Greeks called Romans to liberate them from the Barbarian Macedonians and Ilirians.
Of course Romans never left.
Later on in the 6th century, what is now Greece was settled by Slavs, all the way to Peloponnese. Athens was a Slavic speaking city. Through church and Bisantic administration Slavs in southern part of Greece became Helenised.
What is at present Macedonia, it was the Macedonian population that become Slavenized. The name Greece was adopted for the present territory in the 19th century, before that it was called Rumelia, and thanks for the 2nd Balkan war, Greece got Thessaloniki and what they also cal Macedonia. Soon as they got this territory they ethnically cleansed it not only from Macedonians or by forcefully Helenized their names, they also cleansed of hundreds of thousands of Albanians, Turks and Jews.
On their places they settled their refugees from Anatolia. This is the only a part of the story, I am sure there is more to it.
What is Greece doing now is the same cowardice as Italians by claiming parts of Slovenia and Croatia. When was Yugoslavia Greeks kept their mouth shut, now little Macedonia is easy target. The same was with the Turks.
Greeks never in their history fought one single battle against Turks, but, after Turkey was finished by others, then they became heroes fighting few isolated Turkish garrisons stationed in what is the present Greece.
I'M also a greek macedonian from the hurt af the real macedonia Veria..near vergina where is the tomb of king philip.
Macedonia was a greek kingdom as was back then the other greek city states....sparta...athens...thessaly...thebes....They speak a greek dialect and they loved the same gods.
In 1913 Greece and her allies Serbia and Bulgaria, with the help of more then 100,000 Macedonians who fought along these three armies, drove the Turks out of Macedonia, but Macedonia did not gain its freedom. Instead, the Balkan countries partitioned Macedonia among themselves and Greece occupied the largest part, 51% of the whole territory, called Aegean Macedonia
Even Greeks sources, including the king of Greece himself in 1912, confirm that when the Greek armies occupied Aegean Macedonia the overwhelming majority of the population were NOT Greeks, confirming the fact that the Greeks never lived in Macedonia since the most ancient times (Nikolaides, Spiros Melas Epopee).
But since 1913 Greece begun its assimilatory policies against the Macedonians, changing their family names to Greek names, renaming the cities, rivers, and mountains with Greek names, and forbidding the speaking of the Macedonian language.
Well it seems as though, even under Roman govts; seems to me as though Greeks were always in Macedonia - and the absolute vast majority.
Peasant names in Macedonia in the late 14th century by Andrea Hicks.
http://www.maridonna.com/onomastics...
Hey King of Macedonia - did you know Macedonian Royalty spawned from Argos in Peloponesos ?
Are you suggesting your bloodlines is from Argos?
Or are you simply mis-educated that has no honor in terms of political and intellectual integrity?
Well, what is it going to be?
GO FUCK URSELF ALEXANDROS YOU COCKSUCKING ETHOPIAN DOG IF U WANA SAY SOMETHING SAY IT TO MY FACE U NET WARRIOR I DARE YOU MOTHA FUCKA ILL FUKN TAKE YOU ON CUNT GIME A PLACE & TIME AND ILL MEET U THERE U FUKN POOFTA GREEK MOTHA FUCKA GO TAKE IT UP DA ASS FROM UR PAPOU
Fyrom has only 10% of the land of ancient macedonia.
methodius go back to your cave...slavobulgarian dog.
DID YOU KNOW THAT IN ANCIENT GREECE SAME SEX COUPLES WERE LEGAL INFACT THE GREEKS ALLOWED HOMOSEXUALITY. FACE IT ALEXANDROS & SNOWMAN30 YOUR ANCESTORS WERE GAY AND YOUR HISTORY IS ALL MYTHOLOGY THATS YOU POOFTAS STEAL OUR HISTORY BECAUSE YOU HAVE NO HISTORY THE HISTORY YOUSE HAVE IS THE 300 GAY SPARTANS AND YOUR MYTHOLOGY
AY DICKHEADS IF YOUS WANA START SHIT COME TO BANKSTOWN AND FACE ME THERE NOT ON THE NET YOU FAGGOTS
Now you know why the VETO from NATO & EU.
Not only are you corrupt, but also ridiculous.
Something you may need to know about sex in ancient Greece.
The Greeks understood, perhaps, something we moderns do not; the Greeks understood the "inhuman chaos of nature" and perceived human order as the triumph of the mind and culture over the brute forces of nature. Eros, is not "love" but "sexual desire." It is a representation of how sex attacks the mind and breaks man's will. Eros is a "disease of the soul." Consequently, sexual attraction as madness is a theme that recurs throughout Greek literature. The Greeks saw sex and violence as two sides of the same irrational coin.
To the Greek way of thinking, mind must control the irrational. Subjection to passion and appetite is a form of slavery. The Greeks understood that women possess "a power that speaks to the irrational in men." And ultimately, "what disturbs men about women is what disturbs men about themselves...." Unlike those who would like to portray women as powerless victims of a male patriarchy.
Sure, ancient Greeks were different than we are, but human nature has pretty much remained constant over the last several thousand years. Women were partners in the joint management of Greek society.
This is why Hesiod & Homer promoted the Greek genetical tree so strongly.....and that is why the West knows of the Illiad today.
sadly in these moments only two things come to my mind:
1) why anybody believes that change of the name will fix all the issues Greece has with Macedonia? The point I am trying to make is that the issues they have are much much deeper, and sadly they decided that closing their eyes (forcing name change) will fix them.
2) why on earth Macedonians believe that any agreement with Greece will hold?!?! Why? There is already one agreement which was broken by Greece , why this new one will hold? Because the name is the core issue and fixing the name of Macedonia will fix everything?
The time is going to show that the current negotiations were worthless - Macedonia should recognize that Greece will not respect any agreement.
4
In all these 20 years of our dispute, I have been amazed by the fact that Greeks deeply beleive that we have been brainwashed by Tito and by some miracle the “Macedonia” chip has been somehow implanted in the brains of 2 million people.
I’m honestly curious, how do the Greek interpret the name “Makedonia”? In Macedonian language it means: “Make”=mother + “Don”=home. Makedonia = “Mother Land”. What is the meaning of the word “Makedonia” in Greek?
You guys are keep on skipping the fact that centuries have passed between Alexander and today. Civilizations came and dissapear in this region. The Slavs came there and they married and mixed with the natives. Their language mixed into a new language. Were the natives Greeks? If yes, then we are cousins. The new kings used the ancient symbols: The Alexander Star and the Lyon as the symbols of their kingdomes. Example: King Samouil, X century AD used the Star and the Lyon. Our association with the Star and the Lyon are more related to Samoil than to Alexander. Not only the Slavs used these symbols. The crussaders were putting the Star and the Lyon massively when they were passing through this region. Sir Richard the Lyon-heart has put the Alexander Lyon (Bukefal) on his armor. Later on, the Alexander symbols with some modifications ended up as national symbols of half of the European nations. Example: the Dutch and Belgian Lyons, The three lyons of England. There was another guy from a recent history who used a powerful Alexander symbol in hope that he will regain the Alexander’s glory - Adolf Hitler and the infamous Swastika. When you visit me in Macedonia, I will take to an ancient ruin from the Philip II the Macedonian era - the place is full with swastika’s.
The population identified with the name Macedonia and adopted it. That is why I’m saying, an attempt to localize the Alexander’s legacy in the border or one state and one modern contemporary nation is ridiculous.
You are so loud in your claims in the exclusivity and copyrights on the terms Macedonia and Macedonian, while there is a wide dispute about the topic was Ancient Macedonia Greek or not. I am not a professional historian. I have occasioanly read some pros and cons from worlds sources. But I have read the bible,and Apostle Paul qualifies the region as separate.ie Acts 20v1-3 which is as follows……
” 1)When the uproar had ended, Paul sent for the disciples and, after encouraging them, said good-by and set out for Macedonia.
2) He travelled through that area, speaking many words of encouragement to the people, and finally arrived in Greece,
3) where he stayed three months. Because the Jews made a plot against him just as he was about to sail for Syria, he decided to go back through Macedonia.”
Your recent ethnical and political connection to Macedonia is also shaky. According to the latest Ottoman census from 1905, the population in the Macedonia region was composed of 68% of “Kaurs” - Slavic Speaking Orthodox Christians. The remaining population was consisted of Greeks, Jews, Vlachs and Turks.
Constitutionally, the Greek part of Macedonia has become part of Greece in 1913, and it was not even called Macedonia for quite some time after that. In the period between 1915 -1950, Greece made a massive Hellenization of this region, by changing all the names of the cities and ethnically cleansing almost all Slavic-Macedonians from that region. They were all shipped from the Salonika port to America, Australia, Argentina… during 1915-40, and to Yugoslavia, Russia and Ukraine in 1948-1950. Just check the US immigration registers from 1920s, more than 250 000 slavic macedonians came from Greek Macedonia ( born in Solun, Voden, Lerin, Kostur, Kukush - or what you called today Thessaloniki, florina, Odessa…) These people, as well as their new generations are even today not allowed to enter Greece and at least see the bith places of their grandfathers.
In all these 20 years, the Greek side has done nothing else but brutal force and arrogance. We have seen from the Greek side nothing more than: blocades, embargos, threats, vetos, insults, negations, denials… Every single statement from a Greek official contains an insult and a threat to us. I personally, haven’t seen any genuine attempt from Greece to understaind why were call ourselves Macedonians and what does it means for us.
I can tell to you, we have studied about Alexander not more than 2-3 classes in schools, and that was in the section “World Ancient History”. You have put Alexander in our mouth and many Macedonians started to chew it.
Our side also reacted terrybly in this dispute. We took a position based on the good old Balkan, Donkey-like, stubborness. The more Greeks insult and threat, the more we dig in into the trench. At the end, our economy will go to hell, we will live in the mud, drink water from a river and eat shit and rocks, but we will not “surrender”. This is a suicidal Balkan mentality that has brought for example the Serbs where they are today, and actually us as well with this problem.
I can tell you that many Macedonans are ready to have a compromise if they see that Greece finally stops with the insults and threats and shows some genuine acceptance of Macedonian nation,identity, culture and language. For example, today there are still around 40-50 000 slavic Macedonians living in Greece who are not even allowed to speak their language on the street or publicly state that they are from Slavic origin. Greece can simply recognize these people as ethnic minority. The name does not matter, Greece can call them upper or lower or slavic or ..whathever macedonians.
…gotta go, need to go to a meeting, perhaps later…
IMANASOU INI BOTANI
When was Macedonia Greek I ask you, ancient Macedonia was never Greek, but Greece was Macedonian, Greece was under Macedonian rule. And what is today called Macedonia in Greece, is a territory that Greece occupied in 1913 during the Balkan wars, hundreds of thousands of Macedonians were killed or made refugees since then and Greece is continuing a campaign of ethnic cleansing ever since, I have relatives that have lost their homes in the Greek civil war, and to this day they are still not even allowed to enter Greece simply because they are Macedonians that are a living testimony of the Greek atrocities. Furthermore the territory that Greece now calls Greek Macedonia, until 1988 was simply called Northern Greece, the word Macedonia or Macedonian were not even allowed to be mentioned in Greece as a part of the Greek assimilatory policy over the Macedonians there. Greece changed the province name when it became evident that the Republic of Macedonia will gain independence from Yugoslavia. So I ask you, why does not Greece simply change the name of its province, a province that it’s not even called Macedonia but it’s three regions called East, Central and West Macedonia, which clearly differentiates from the Republic of Macedonia. I am just angered at the injustice that the world tolerates, simply because, they see Greece as a pet that the western world sees as the “cradle of democracy”. What kind of democracy is this when we as Macedonians are denied our basic right of freedom to speak our identity, our name, our history etc. The Greeks don’t really want us to change our name, that is not the real problem for them. THEY WANT US TO JUST DISAPEAR, because we are a thorn in their eye, because we are a living proof of the crimes they did over the Macedonian population during the past 100 and more years, because we can prove it, because our existence threatens their utopist vision of a pure Greek nation (which is a non-sense on its own), because minorities in Greece don’t even have the basic human rights (Macedonians, Turks, Albanians, Vlahs). Don’t believe me, go in Greece and speak out in a bar or somewhere “I’m a Macedonian” and see what happens.
Hm, if this issue is so important to Former Ottoman Province of Younanistan, why don't you just invade Macedonia? Then you can call it as you wish. Or, if Macedonia is yours, how come that you let some smallish countries divide it???
Until then, Macedonia will choose its name... As 200+ other countries did.
(Don't tell me that waving with some pictures of Prime minister in front of some monument consists of a proof of iredentism. Don't make the Royal British forces in Northern Ireland laugh at you... Or Spanish forces in their iredentist places... Or french ... )
Not a single country has the right to name another country. And, yes, we have some ancestry from Filip and Aleksandar. And I have to say - maybe the strongest ancestry because we kept their name. Just check official archives for Macedonian immigrants in USA (Ellis island, ...) in 1890-1930... Long before Tito...
And now we sold out the Serbs and we will enter Nato on April 3rd. Under the name of "Republika Makedonija" i.e. the holy constitutional name, but without English (or French or any other) translation. Just pure constitutional name without translation...
BECAUSE IT IS GOOOOOOOOD FOR THE FOPoY also... You will get extra defense, NATO will get clear path to the occupied territories of Serbia...
Long live the newly restored centuries long friendship between Macedonia and FOPoY. Don't get us wrong, but Filip didn't know that destroying democracy and giving you monarch will deny your freedom for like 20 centuries after his occupation...
If you weren't brainwashed in Yugoslavia.
Then where were was your ethnic representation in the 1913 Teaty of Bucharest and 1919 Treaty of Nuilly?
Ahhh, that's right you self declared yourselves as Bulgarian then.
...then during WW2 you know longer wanted to be with the fascist Bulgarians..so being communist south slavs/Bulgarians with the old dream of taking Greek soil...you suddenly became "Macedonian"....
May I remind you what was said in 1944 by the United States?
"This Government considers talk of Macedonian "nation", Macedonian "Fatherland", or Macedonia "national consciousness" to be unjustified demagoguery representing no ethnic nor political reality, and sees in its present revival a possible cloak for aggressive intentions against Greece". U.S Secretary Of State STETTINIUS-26 Dec. 1944
U KNO WOT I KNO WOT I AM I KNO WHO I AM I KNO WERE I COME FROM I DONT CARE WOT YOUS SAY OR WOT YOUS DO I AM MACEDONIAN
MACEDONIA FOR THE MACEDONIANS
for george:
please check your passport => it has section with name and nationality. Then please write back what you are your findings.
Now, read this very carefully:
I am Macedonian, born and raised in R. Macedonia, but my roots are from Kostur (I am not going to translate the name for you asshole - its time to get used to it). I am and I was always Macedonian. Not because Tito said so, but because my grandparents said so. In clear Macedonian language. And I do possess property there.
In a way, I and the others like me are your problem - you can hide it, but not forever.
And one more thing: I don't want to have anything to do with Alexander the Great - you can have the honor of being descendant of the murderer on pair with Hitler - although he started with the ancient Greek people.
Can you George process all this? Do you understand?
Wasn't Macedonia for Macedonians said by Tatar-chev in Thessaloniki, being educated and traioned in Sofia - Bulgaria?
So that slogan is used to annexe Hellenic soil.?
Well, I must say it seems as though you people have yet to grow up. Then you wonder, why the VETO will be unfair.
Do you want me to understand why you want to mis appropriate the personality of my character and turn it into a Slav?
Yes, I, fully processed it.
It's not going to happen.
We really want to help, but how can we when you want to annexe everything up to Mount Olympus?
I understand you have been bought up believing in something, but I simply do not accept you trodding on my toes and mis representing the personality of my character.
You are south slavs/yugoslavs. Why be ashemed of that?
Surely you can do better than being a cop & paste propagandist?
Oh btw you can take out the periods between 1913 to 1944, you were self declared Bulgarian. There is no Macedonian ethnicity on any official treaty, agreement or diplomatic paper signed by your ethnic group during this period. Simply because you did not exist as an ethnic group.
george, I am ok with you guys. I have no problem with whatever you want to call yourself. I have problem with what you want from me - and that is not for sale nor giving. I don't want anything from you - neither the property I posses there (greece). Cheer up!
Having said this, it must be painful to watch yourself in the mirror every day - that nice tan and dark hair sure can be fixed - don't worry you are the Filiphos grand grand grandson with some sunburn. I accept that.
I am sorry you need to get racist mak-guy.
But I can assure you I don't have dark hair.
You want to call yourselves after a Greek tribe. Then educate yourselves inline with what Macedonia really stands for.
Otherwise, VETO.
No skin off my nose, you are the ones with internal turmoil with the Albanian population.
to mak-guy: another part of that agreement was that FYROM was to actively participate in finding a suitable and mutually acceptable name - but instead over a period of 15 years it has vehemently refused any compromise and has instead followed a stance of intransigence.
Instead of working with Greece, FYROM thought that it could hope the issue would go away by trying to get as many countries as it could to recognise its constitutional name... What about when FYROM UN representatives introduced the FYROM leader in the UN as the "President of the Republic of Macedonia"... How is this within the UN interim agreement?
Its position all along during these talks has been to "show to Greece the reality" (i.e. that the constitutional name is the only option)... FYROM needs to undertand that in reality their nation is not going to function as a viable state in the Balkans without the assistance of the euro-atlantic organisations. FYROM needs Greece to approve its membership - so FYROM needs Greece more than Greece needs FYROM.
It is time for FYROM to abandon their intransigence and think of its future as a nation and the future of its people.
What Greece has proposed is not by any means compromising FYROM's national identity or culture. Greece is not saying they cannot be 'Macedonians', Greece is saying they can be Macedonians TOO! but that 2.5 million Greeks are also Macedonians - and there needs to be a distinction because these two groups are very different both in terms of their culural ancestry and language.
Prepare for two weeks of political spin from both sides. From what I have observed in the stance of FYROM in the last 4 weeks is that they have progressively become less and less unwilling to discuss a composite name - which i see merely as a gesture to the international community to show that they have been accommodating and have tried their best to solve the problem.
This is how I see the next month playing out.
1. 2 weeks of intensive negotiations under UN/US auspices.
2. At least 2 more proposals will be put on the table (to which FYROM will show vague interest to put on the act like it really wants to solve the problem)
3. Ultimately FYROM will reject all proposals
4. Greece will veto FYROM's accession into NATO - after last minute failed efforts by the US to change Greece's stance. FYROM will be dumbfounded that Greece actually went through with their threat because we can all tell that they think Greece is all talk.
5. Croatia and Albania enter NATO
6. Albania will demand greater rights for ethnic Albanians in FYROM in order for them to approve FYROM's eventual accession into NATO
7. FYROM is in an even worse position than it is now.
This is of course assuming that there isnt another civil war in FYROM in the coming years.
daniel, I agree with most of what you stated, except with your view of the development of events.
would you please re-read it and say it would be the same 15 years ago? honest?
So, you see , there is a progress. You have become more receptive to the reality.
One thing I really want to say is that RMacedonia exists because of Macedonians, not opposite. It really does not matter what and how the things are going to play - the people there will still be macedonians.
p.s. I really feel sorry for you guys that you will be forced to veto Macedonia entrance in NATO because you can not let all think Greece is all talk. It is really great reason, isn't it?
I think you know perfectly well what the reasons are.
It's your irredentism and intransigence, if you really wanted to know.
Your expansionist maps in your schools and the mis representation of a personality which is alien to south slavs/yugoslavs.
Mak-guy,
I guess what I was trying to get across is that FYROM needs to assess their situation. They do not have the bargaining power to make absolutely no concessions in the name talks.
Greece has national interests to protect also and they will use their right to Veto for this reason alone - not because they just 'can' or because they dont want the international community to see them lose this argument.
FYROM needs to meet Greece half way on this. Both countries' best interest lie in a lasting solution.
P.S I agree Greece's initial stance to FYROM's declaration of independence was harsh and Greece has come to realise that if they do not compromise then they will be the ones that international pressure will exerted on (as is the case with FYROM right now with the latest proposals that "seem to favour the Greek position")
Furthermore there is no need to feel sorry for Greece when they eventually use veto - because ultimately the world will feel sorry for FYROM's position of intransigence - because that alone will be the downfall of FYROM.
hahaha george, you funny guy...
so, the name of the country is not a problem but "mis representation of a personality" is the problem??
You know what - I actually agree with you. You simply can not erase us.
daniel - its true in all that you said.
The situation is not pinkish for sure for RMacedonia. I sense that name change is almost done deal.
And I have no beef with the final solution, I do not live there and I can not say what they should do.. I will be open and say that I will nod on the final solution. It will not change me, who I am, nor my family tree.
One thing I can say is the following: It will be tough sell in R.Macedonia. Depending of the wording and how it affects our identity it can go from 2 second fly, to civil war and terrorist acts. If the deal is going to later, please understand that veto is better then getting into nato. For us, at least.
p.s. thank you for being civilized and restraining from telling me what I should be - it really upsets me.
If our prime minister sells the name not only he will burn, but greeks will burn, bulgarians will burn and everyone who denies MACEDONIA and MACEDONIANS will burn. Everything you did to us for centuries will return triple.
I want to explain some things in order to make my position clear:
1.) I never said that people of FYROM are not Macedonians. They are as well as the GreekMacedonians or the Bulgarian-Macedonians are.
2.) Alexander the Great is Greek because history sais so, and trust me its not the history written from the greek state but eons bedore its creation.
3.) I never said that I am a descedant of Alexander the Great. If I had to choose be sure that I would like Perickles as my ascenstor.
4.) If FYROM wants to call herself Macedonia it is her right. But a state under this name will never join the EU or NATO because it is needed to have good relations with its neighbours
5.) I am surprised of that presentation of Balkan history in some comments. But probably they have no idea of how Balkan people are behaving all these centuries and they regard as natural that beeing Macedonian is the right only of ''Macedonians''...If it was so simple the Balkan Peninsula would be Scandinavia-like.
6.) I am surprised that whenever I post an article related to Macedonia almost 100 comments arrive from ''opressed'' people, with perfect knowledge of history and full of democratic sentiments.
Really when I post issues related to the quality of modern democracy and all these why I only get 0 or 1 comments? ???
You are also pushing the FTROG (Former Turkish Republic of Greece) point of view by repeditely using the term FYROM instead of Macedonia!
IT IS MACEDONIA AND WILL ALWAYS BE!
Greeks say that the Macedonians a Greek, Bulgarians say that the Macedonians are Bulgarian, thats what happens when you take someone else's land, and the Macedonians say we always been Macedonian.
COMMON SENCE listen to the Macedonians cos we know our identity. We dont steal history from other countries like the Greeks and Bulgarians.
we have nothing to prove to anyone i am macedonian my grandad is macedonian his grandad is macedonian as is my grandad's grandad my country is the republic of macedonia and it has always been whether in yugoslavia or not we have always been called macedonia and our country the republic of macedonia 120 countries around the world recognize the republic of macedonia i live today and i am not in NATO i lived yesterday and i wasnt in NATO therefore i will live tomorow without NATO so if you want to VETO macedonia's enterance to NATO you are welcome all that will achieve is pressure on your goverment and hostility in diplomatic relations with many nations around the world and also less macedonian solders will be deployed to fight in iraq nothing more will be achieved by a VETO greece does not scare macedonia we will not be bullied we will not give up time is on our side everyday more countries recognize macedonia
I think the Serbian situation sould merit some thought. It was nationalism that took her down. Maybe one day the Greeks will unravel by western pressure.
Macedonians, never give up your fight for FREEDOM!
It is your God given.
Greeks with a MERE one hundred year history as so called Macedonians in Aegean Macedonia should know this......TRUTH IS THE DAUGHTER OF TIME.
Your veto threat has done more to bring the truth to the world about the theft and hellinisation attempts on our nationality,people,places,history, artefacts, the list is endless ,than we could have ever prayed for.
I hope your veto threat is genuine,i hope your government goes ahead with it,for it will surely create such international interest that your government will finally be exposed.
King of Macedon has shown there are too many of your own documents showing the systematic destruction of all things Macedonian by the Greek government to ever deny that our Macedonian culture truly existed along with its people in Aegean Macedonia way before annexation to this current day.
You forced changes in peoples names!
how disgusting and dispicable is that?
think about that,The Nazis killed many many Jews but at least they died with their identities in tact.
The most dishounarable world event in the last 100 years of international history has to be forced changes to ones given and family names,you changed a whole culture.
Are you people for real?People had their babies christened with these names and you forced Greek names upon them,
how dare you! Now your at it AGAIN!!!!
FYROM should be made stop its ridiculous attemts to steal history from its neighbours Greece and even more so from Bulgaria.
History theft is Identity theft and is not a petty matter, it is a CRIME.
Hey spassov,
havent you been paying attention........
ITS THE OTHER WAY AROUND>>>
The documents are starting to find their way to the rest of the World, the real World, not the world you are living in.
TRUTH IS THE DAUGHTER OF TIME
nasha Makedonia
1920:
Professor R.A. Reiss reports to the Greek government: "Those whom you would call Bulgarian speakers I would simply call Macedonians...Macedonian is not the language they speak in Sofia...I repeat the mass of inhabitants there (Macedonia) remain simply Macedonians."
from your own Greek archives!
Your government is fooling you,as it fooled your fathers before you.
TRUTH IS THE DAUGHTER OF TIME!
Spassov, why don't you get a gun and shoot us all?
Its a real solution for what you want from us - to stop existing.
ANCIENT MACEDONIA
http://video.google.com/videoplay?d...
I think this debate is ridiculous. What if FYROM enters NATO under the name of New Macedonia and than a week after the accession it changes its name in the United Nations to Macedonia? The problem with naming things other than their names is that they don't stick - I don't know any European country where the people or the press or politicians would refer to Macedonia differently than Macedonia. NATO is a military alliance which would be more powerful if Macedonia joined. I think this naming game should not have an effect on NATO, and that is mostly the responsibility of the Greek government. Obviously, the Macedonian government should do anything to stop the Greek worrying about their identity and security, but I think these kind of absurd debates make Central Europe vulnerable.
The right to self declaration is right each and everyone nation has. Macedonia is shown in the bible and not greece, if anything greece should change its name, but wait they already did! prior to 1988 Greek Macedonia as the greeks now call it was referred to in all official state matters as northern greece so from 1913 to 1988 Northern Greece was its official name, funny how macedonia should change its name considering that name has been used for over 3,000 years.. and the greeks have only used the name for 20 years and annexed this part of Macedonia 95 years ago.
Greeks cannot claim direct lineage to Alexander the Great as mentioned above by Goste these christian turks from Anatolia who could not even speak greek 100 years ago are new comers to the land while macedonians have remained even after attempts to assimilate them.
Modern greeks are a nation of albanians, slavs, arabs, vlachs, jews and refugess from Asia Minor
Greece has the highest incidence of the J Hapoltype marker (which is common in Arab lands) cause its population is not native to the land they are decedents of Arvanites Albanians from the 15th centurary along with Christians Turks from Asia Minor, Vlachs, slavs and Macedonians who were assimilated to produce this artificial nation.
Also Slavs did arrive in Macedonia and the Balkans but not in the numbers once believed, like most nations Macedonia has been conquered and over run by other tribes nations but Macedonians should not be called Slavic Macedonians but simply Macedonians, the Slavs were not warriors but farmers who assimilated with the native population, The MACEDONIAN POPULATION. No one refers to the Russians as Slavic Russians or Serbs as Slavic Serbs when referring to their ethnicity so why should Macedonians suffer this injustice. modern nations are a mixture of different ancient and modern peoples.
The Former Ottoman Republic of Western Turkey, Greece - FOROWTG is trying to eliminate the macedonians and along with it the truth that Macedonia never belonged to Greece.
I forgot to mention - was Alexander's mother Olympia (sounds greek to me) was his teacher Aristotle (obviously greek). So does that mean that the skopjians want to claim Alexander as their own, even though he was greek? i dont understand? I thought one major legacy that Alexander gave the world was that he spread hellenic customs and language throughout the eastern world. if he was anti greek why would he spend his life promoting hellenism throughout the known world. ??? thats why its called the helleistic period you donkeys.....
slav macedonians argue that the greek government changed their family names, if this is fact, then why do you people still carry your greek names. you all cry and argue, but continue using your so called forced names???
You want to get to know the Balkans? Read this whole hullabaloo here and you'll get the gist of it.
This is a fight of inferiority complexes, especially what the Macedonians do. People, just swallow it - Alexander the Great has nothing to do with contemporary Macedonians! It's so absurd to claim otherwise. It's ridiculous! It won't make you any better! (And, for the record, I'm not even Greek)
To hristo,
You say the mother and teacher of alexander the great were Greek but the father which is king Philip of MACEDON.
Not king philip of Greece is it.
Republic of Macedonia since: 1944
The first plenary session of ASNOM was convened on the symbolic date of August 2 (Ilinden-Preobrazhenie uprising day) 1944 in the St. Prohor Pcinjski Monastery in modern Serbia, near the Macedonian town of Kumanovo. The most important assembly decisions are the proclaming Macedonia nation-state of ethnic Macedonians, proclamation of the Macedonian language as the official language of the Macedonian state. The citizens of Macedonia, regardless of their ethnic affiliation, were guaranteed all civil rights, as well as the right to their mother tongue and confession of faith.
Northern Province of Macedonia (in Greece) since: 1988
Greece did not refer to any part of its current territory as Macedonia until 1988, when Papandreou's government officially adopted the name Macedonia to replace that of Northern Greece.
WHO SHOULD CHANGE THIER NAME NOW?
There is only ONE Macedonia and that is the GREEK Macedonia.
And, for those who think that we will give up fighting to protect our history and what is ours - think twice!
MAKEDONIA KSAKOUSTH TOY ALEXANDROU H HORA !!
ZHTO H ELLAS !!!!!!!!!!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X2F0...
http://www.freewebs.com/onoma/metan... is fine with you?
Listen to me carefully - the only step back that Macedonia will do for the Karamanlis governement of The former Ottoman Province of Younanistan is that we will not translate our Constitutional name for few years. That is - we will be accepted as "Republika Makedonija" in NATO AND EU.
Just look around - the only NATO aspiring country that involved ALL of its territory for NATO mission is Macedonia since Kosovo campaign in 1999, i.e. we are the most deserving for a membership... Or we should close our borders for NATO troops?
Natasha Your history is a myth formed to oppress Macedonian, Turkish, Pomak, Vlachian, Arvanitic, Latin Catholic, and Jewish minorities of Greece.
Macedonians became minority due to the unhumane torture and genocide explained above which is continuing to this very day.
You can't go on like that forever, you need to face your past and correct your actions.
People have the right to speak and write their own language, have their own names and culture.
YOUR SO CALLED HISTORY CREATED YOUR MYTHICAL NATION AND FASCIST STATE.
Your illusion or interpretation of history do not give you the right to tell someone who he is and what his name should be.
You may fool the world with you great greekness(and your latest trend macedonia is ours) but you can't fool us, we know who you are, we suffered from your greek phanariots since forever and they were the only greek thing torturing everybody with their death greek language. Macedonian was the language spoken all over the Aegean and is still spoken in Aegean Macedonia and Turkey despite your NAZI behavior.
And again, we are Macedonians and our country is MACEDONIA and will always be.
People of the Balkans need to realize that they have more in common than they have to fight about. All this petty squabbling that is evident even from reading all of these posts is just giving the West the right to look down upon us. Division is weakening the Balkans! Unity is the answer.
I see a common trend here - the citizens of both countries are arguing historical factors for either keeping or changing the official name of FYROM.
I find it interesting that the government of FYROM hasn't used any of these historical arguments to counter Greece's demand for a name change.
FYROM's leaders have never linked their ancentry to Ancient Macedonians in their arguments to keep their constitutional name (several former leaders have even admitted that they are decendants of Slavic tribes that settled in the Balkans centuries after the fall of Macedon) - yet the citizens of FYROM do make the ancestrial link to ancient Macedon.
FYROM's leaders have never claimed that Greece has perpetrated a systematic annihilation of the 'ethnic Macedonian' populations of Greece in arguing to keep their constitutional name - yet the citizens of FYROM have claimed this. Genocide is a serious crime against humanity and Greece would have been held accountable for this HAD the conditions of genocide existed.
If the 'ethnic Macedonians' of Greek Macedonia believe that their ancestors (or themselves as may be the case) were victimised and systematically annihilated through "genocide and torture" then they should take this issue up with the international human rights courts and see that Greece is disciplined for its alleged actions. Why hasn't this happened? Who is stopping the 'ethnic-Macedonian' diaspora from taking such action? they shouldn't fear Greek intimidation because they obviously no longer reside in Greece.
It is interesting that the government of FYROM has never made these arguments yet the citizens of the country continue to regurgitate them at nausium.
As for the use of the term 'the Former Ottoman Republic of Greece/Yunanistan' - I find it ironic that a people who were also under Ottoman occupation (in fact for almost 100 years more than the Peloponnese and Central Greece were) think that this is in some way a derogative reference to Greece and Greeks - you are only inadvertantly insulting yourselves.
Lastly I reiterate the realities of this situation. Greece is a member of NATO and the EU - two organisations that FYROM wishes to join. The onus is on FYROM to press for a viable solution with Greece. Greece has its veto right and it is entitled to use it. If FYROM doesn't come to terms with this in the next 15 days it will have to settle for a future of instability and uncertainty outside the euroatlantic structures.
To put 'New' or 'Upper' in front of Macedonia or to potential cease to exist all together... you would think that this was a no brainer.
Daniel,
The Former Ottoman Republic of Yunanistan is falsifying history. Check legal archives to see the Laws of renaming places in Northern FOPOY. If your government is so sure that Macedonia is "Greek" why bother renaming places?
Secondly, THERE IS NO NEED to invoke history. Do you really believe that history stops at Sehovo (now Idomeni) and continues in Serbia? Do you really believe that we imported history from somewhere else so we can claim the right to nationality? Do you really believe that whole nation has nothing better to do, but to steal "greek" history?
C'mon, wake up - in 15 days Macedonia will enter NATO. Your (and ours) government plays the theather of shadows... Nothing is like it seems it is - almost 15 years ago, our countries agreed to fix the wrongdoing of Konstantin Mitsotakis, Antonis Samaras and friends... And we sold ourselves to NATO - Serbs are occupied by forces that come from FOPOY or Bulgaria to Kosovo. THROUGH Macedonia. That is the only reason why we will get the NATO membership easily...
Othes possibility is VETO. It is breaking the Interim accord from 1995. It means the "name negotiations" are over. The very next day we go to UN to have our name back, we sue FOPOY for the breach of the UN brokered Interim accord, and we continue to live in a special deal with Americans to allow them to pass through our country. We will just ask them for protection. With EU we have the Stabilization and association agreement that can be extended. Don't forget that after 2014 EU starts to change its consensus rules...
As we lived through the embargo in 1992 (check EEC archives to see that EEC started a legal process against the embargo), through 50 years of communism, 5 years of WWII, 40 years of serbian rule, 500 years of Ottoman rule, 10 centuries of Roman Empire rule, etc, etc... we will live through this nuissance.
But, FOPOY governments will have to explain how come UN easily registers us as "Republic of Macedonia" this time. How come the ICJ rules that the accession in 1992 was flawed i.e. not a single other country was imposed a fifth condition... And, maybe, why all the assets of FOPOY companies in Macedonia are frozen until mutual recognition?
Beware... Our position is clear - we will do no harm. We do not want YOUR history because we have ours.
Finaly - I do not hate anyone. It's just unimaginable that I will allow someone else to christen me. Just watch your reaction when I christen you with the name of FOPOY. For real, my grandfather fought for Macedonia to be free. His grandfather too (in foreign armies). I have no right to rename my country because of them. But if you want me to, you will have to take arms and come to fight as I will defend my right with blood.
Proud Macedonian,
Skopje, Macedonia
After reading the comments from the Slavs who actually believe they have some connection to ancient Macedonia, I can only conclude that they must be insane - totally out of touch with reality.
I guess this is understandable; who wouldn't want to have a history as glorious as that of the Greeks? How else could they make themselves feel important or relevant? More importantly, if these Slavs are not true Macedonians, then what are they? What identity DO they have? What unites them? The answer is nothing.
The problem is that coming to terms with this reality would lead to the disintegration of their country, so grasping on to any identity they can associate with, even if this is based on lies, propaganda, and brainwashing, is essential to their existence.
It is interesting to see how easily an entire population can be completely brainwashed within a few decades.
If the Slavs who have replied to this article actually believe what they say, then they would stop promoting websites filled with ridiculous propaganda (these only make you look even more ignorant), and they would do some objective research on the real history of Macedonia. I suggest you weigh the evidence presented by both sides with an open mind before spewing your b.s. on the internet.
Proud Macedonian,
What was the point of signing an interim agreement with Greece if FYROM had no intention to seek a mutually acceptable solution to the problem? The interim agreement is a farce - Article 5 states that the two sides should seek a mutually acceptable solution to the dispute of the name - When has FYROM ever actually done this? FYROM have merely attended meetings to show to the international community that they are actively involved in talks and behind the scenes have done nothing but mount a campaign to promote recognition of the country under the constitutional name. Further evidence was in 2007 when UN General Assembly president Srgjan Kerim (a citizen of FYROM) introduced President Crvenkovski within the UN using FYROM’s constitutional name. It can be argued that they have already breached article 5 of the Interim Agreement and contravened Security Council resolutions 817 (1993) and 843 (1993).
Interim agreement or no Interim agreement FYROM will still have a neighboring state that refuses to recognize them and will still not be a member of NATO or the EU. Face it, FYROM needs to gain membership to NATO as soon as possible for its own protection from the issues that lie within its borders (not so much outside).
Fact of the matter is Greece sees this time as the only opportunity to settle this dispute with an uncooperative FYROM. If FYROM seriously believed that they could fall back on the interim agreement they wouldn't even bother responding to any of Greece's threats and could merrily continue living their joyful existence of recognition ambiguity.
Lastly, Greece is not an aggressor state. It has endured 15 years of negotiations to prove this. I do not blame you for being passionate about this issue but there will never be a reason for you to ‘lay arms’ to defend FYROM from your southern neighbor. The only military threat to FYROM lies within its borders and the 2001 conflict was a testament to this reality.
Daniel,
Well - it takes two to tango. BOTH PARTIES JUST ATTENDED THE MEETINGS AND NEVER INTENDED TO SOLVE IT PROPERLY. FOPOG is like 5 times bigger and 25 times economically better off than Macedonia. So, you are telling me that if there was real intent for negotiations from your party it wouldn't speed up the things? It wasn't in you interest at all to negotiate, and our politicians just didn't realize what would happen at the end. Or they both did and now they are playing theater of shadows with public in both countries?
And regarding campaigning - did you truly believe that nonviolent campaigning could be stopped even with any accord? It's about a name - there is no precedent that any other country did the same thing that FOPOG did to Macedonia. Even Belgium spared Luxembourg. Or France did nothing to Grand Bretagne. C'mon if the problem is irrational and so simple to solve - you call your Macedonia as Greek Macedonia or Northern Greece and we will call our Macedonia as "REPUBLIC of Macedonia". Everybody will spot the difference.
If Mr. Kerim calls his own country with unconstitutional name can he be prosecuted in Macedonia? Whose law takes precedence? Khm, is UN Resolution a law? Isn't UN extra territorial?
Finally - breach of Interim accord is not in your favor. Even that we breached it first. Do you know the scale of Macedonian investments in FOPOG that will be frozen if the Interim accord is broken? Close to zero. Do you know that FOPOG is the second biggest investor in Macedonia? What will National Bank of Greece or Veroupoulos or TITAN or Elbisko think if their assets are frozen. Some food for thought - do you know that ECJ had a case against 1994 embargo? Check case nr. C-120/94R on Eur-Lex. Read the fine print - broken Interim accord means that we are free to go to the ICJ to fix our accession with fifth condition. Read Article 21, paragraph 2 that will free us to go to ICJ.
Regarding the instability - if we didn't break in 1994, we will not break now, don't worry about us. But ask NATO how it will send troops to Kosovo from Larissa or Burgas?
RECOGNITION AMBIGUITY lol ROTFLOL ... This is the best part... Search for Macedonia on the web and you will get your Pan-Macedonian network on the third page or so. All the other links are from Republic of Macedonia.
Finally - within our borders? Or orchestrated and imported from Kosovo? We are over it - thanks to the GREEK military help my friend. Because we are part of NATO. Since 1998 when we let NATO invade Kosovo from Macedonia. Not a single new NATO member or aspirant did that for NATO. Only we did it. And we were helped by our southern neighbor.
Your politicians just turned almost 180 degrees. In 1992 all the politicians of FOPOG insisted they will never accept a name with Macedonia in it. On March 24ht, Ms. Bakoyannis said that there is wider geographical region of Macedonia. And she said that Republic of Macedonia is a part of it. And that we can keep the term in the name (thank you Ms. Bakoyanni). What is next? We can keep the term Macedonia if there are at least two more letters with it? Or a letter and a number? Or two uppercase letters?
Ms. Bakoyanni recognized our name. Now it is only a technicality how to overcome the problems that your politicians will have with explaining to your people how come that change happened. Explaining to all the 100.000 people that are still interested in the issue.
In 10 days you will see reformed temporary reference. Instead of "the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia" that we accept but do not agree with it (Macedonia never signs documents under the reference), we will get our constitutional name "Republika Makedonija" in use. Yes, in original but written in Latin alphabet. For like 10 or 15 years we will start freely to translate it in English. With obligatory "Republic of" in front of the holy name of Macedonia. Because we all know that there are two more parts of Macedonia...
Accept the reality. Stop the defamation of our nation and just come to spend some euro in Macedonia (as we do in your country). You will see that we are your best neighbor.
Daniel..this isn't maknews forum to repeat your slavobulgarian propaganda.The greek macedonians who are the majority will mever permit fyromians to use exclusively the name macedonia.
Daniel..this isn't maknews forum to repeat your slavobulgarian propaganda.The greek macedonians who are the majority will mever permit fyromians to use exclusively the name macedonia.
gotse....go back to maknews shithole and stay there....with yoyr slav friends.And yoyr name is GIORGOS.
the best thing about you greeks calling northern greece macedonia is that the indigenous families trapped there since annexation in 1913 can once again say they are from their beloved macedonia instead of the despised northern greece.
To top it off how about renaming all the people back to their original indigenous macedonian names instead of the greekanised versions that have been forced upon them for almost 100 years.
surely that would show your sincerety towards the "name issue"
snowman30,
what are you talking about? where is my slavobulgarian propaganda?
to all of you out there, what this has shown me is that the slav macedonian skopians are dead set in their thinking. they are not interested in negotiating or talking and they have rediculous ideas about their history. they believe in conspiracy theories and propaganda. but they are allowed to say and do as they wish. the greeks should continue to behave like gentlemen and diplomats, and with common sense. all orthodox balkan states have a underlying hatred for the turks who oppressed them during the ottoman period. however the skopians are looking to them for help and are strong allies. surely 400 years of oppression does not bother the skopians.
Hristaki,
Just read up a bit. I invited you to come and invade my country. So we can be even. We invaded you 20 centuries ago and you now. But we did not change your name. Ahaia? Or Athens? Or Teba? Or Sparta...
Forgot to mention:
You will have 4 more millions of Albanians gratis with the occupation... As you love them as much to ally with them...
dear proud macedonian, i am a macedonian, and i am greek, as are my ancestors before me. (and guess what- we are not refugees from asia minor as has been stated) and guess what, i come from the northernmost villages of florina and kastoria, bordering albania and FYROM. And infact, my uncle lives in Bitola (monostiri) and he is greek. But you would not understand, that us greeks inhabit greek macedonia - the way you talk would it seems as if greek macedonia is full of slavs???
as can be seen by the replies of all skopians, they are crude. the slav macedonians displaced from greece want a country. how absurd. should the greeks in Bitola that where displaced or the greeks from Instanbul or Smyrna ask for compensation and land back.........the wars of 1912-13 resulted in the borders of today. the greek portion of macedonia has more greeks in it than 100 years ago, as the FYROM portion has more slavs and the Bularian portion more bulgars than 100 years ago. The slavs dream of asking for greek macedonia to join as one nation is ridiculous.
I have a thought - FYROM should disintergrate - give some of it land to ALbania, and join Greece. Then the Skopians and call themselves Macedonians and believe what the want. In return, Greece should give them rights of a minority and seats in parlaiment - and protection. The skopians must think of there wellbeing and future, - the way they are thinking will leave them on the outer with the EU and NATO, infact may not survive as it is.
PS Why doesnt Greek macedonia break away from greece and call itself Republic of Macedonia,(just like Cyprus with main language as greek and greek flag ) (and use the name so that the skopians dont use it) and then in 15 years when FYROM disintergrates , rejoin Greece.
the prime minister of greece is macedonian, - and has stated that to the european parliament -made front page news. yes, he is a greek macedonian.
on the topic of the name issue... its very interesting that after this latest round of talks we haven't yet heard anything about what actually happened...
a solution may be nigh?
Hristo,
Sorry, but I think schizophrenia might be a definition. Or separate personality? I am a bird and a dog. Greek and Macedonian (in ethnic terms). Fish and whale.
It simply can't be. You are a Macedonian in geographic terms, but by Greek nationality. Evan that your parents are slavophone...
It's up to you to self-declare your nationality. I can't tell you what are you. But you can't be both, isn't it so?
Cheerz
Greek and macedonian is the same thing from the time of philip...proud slavobulgarian.
Pathetic neonazis.
With your pseudo-historical knowledge, so-called 'Greeks' and 'Macedonians'...
If you were even remotely aware of history, you would know that no entities such as 'Greece' or 'Macedonia' ever existed since the time of the Macedonian Wars, whereby Roman general Caecilius Metellus defeated Andriscos of Macedonia and the Achaean League of Greece at the Battle of Pydna in 148 BC and Corinth in 146 BC respectively, turning Macedonia and Achaia (Greece) into Roman Provinces.
Since then, major historical turning points took place, WHICH YOU SEEM TO IGNORE, fools. The Apostle Paul declared the one and only Christian Ethnos, and by the 3rd century AD, the Capital of Rome was transferred to Byzantium (Constantinople).
Thus, all Christian subjects to the Empire became part of the one Christian nation: ROME. In the East, aka VASILEIA ROMAION/ROMANIA, the multilingual nation identified as ROMAIOI, which, survived the Ottoman rule as ROMIOI.
Both modern Greeks and Macedonians have been 'Romaioi' AT LEAST since Patriarch Photius dispatched Sts Cyril and Methodius in 862 AD to Moravia, evangelising the Slavs.
A single visit to a monastery in Greece or Macedonia will proove even to the most resilient of disbelievers that both people are ORTHODOX, demonstrating clearly the ROMAIC heritage of ALL BALKAN PEOPLE, and in particular, Greeks and Macedonians.
Until recently, both Greeks and Macedonians were even attending Church IN THE SAME BUILDINGS, SIMULTANEOUSLY, the liturgies being held in Romaic (Greek) and Old Church Slavonic (Macedonian), yet, the scripts were prepared in THE SAME, NON-SLAVIC ALPHABET.
A single look at the script of the Konikovo Gospel, published in Thessaloniki, Macedonia in 1852, prooves without a shadow of doubt that I am telling you the truth. Here, look:
http://www.helsinki.fi/~jslindst/26...
It's so obvious what nationalism can do in the balcans.
It is so clear what propagana can make after some decades.
The solution is so clear. No entry to Nato and EU for FYROM.
Till they find a way to respect their neighbors and also calm down a bit.
i hope also we greeks learn some more things about what happened back in the history, we were not perfect for sure.
But we were not fighting macedonians back then, we were fighting against bulgaria I suppose. Bulgaria doesn't accuse greece of attrocities as far as i know. There was no "macedonian ethnicity back then. It's a new idea born the last century.
In any case, greece will simply exercise it's right for not accepting this country to be a member of both Nato and EU.
SO simple.THis issue has to somehow settled down otherwise it will create problems for sure.
Now , if some people would like to call themselves Macedonians, then they are free to do so.
But when they make propaganda and connect themselves to ancient macedonia, then it's getting near to a tragedy.
For the time being , FYROM people they will just not be invited to enter neither EU or Nato.
How come so many Greeks have a problem with undoing the Caps Lock button?
Is it because they are physically as well as mentally blind?
Blind to the propaganda they have been fed about their recent past: the expulsion of the Jews from Salonika/Solun and the expulsion of Slavs from their homes in Northern Greece to make way for Greeks from Asia Minor?
Is it so difficult for you to live with yourselves? Perhaps it is because you resemble Ancient Greeks so very little that you dare not look in the mirror?
The only things evocative of the culture of Ancient Greece about modern 'Greeks' are the words 'tragic', 'hysterical', 'pathetic' and 'xenophobic'.
Take a national DNA test and find out what you are. Meanwhile,grow up or shut the f up. Everyone in Europe is sick of you--the 'Bully of the Balkans'.
Let's clarify a few things:
1) Alexander the Great was greek because that's what he thought of himself and that's what historians in the universities around the world say. He spoke greek, he believed in the greek gods. Believing that modern Slavomacedonias (or FYROMinians) are descendants of ancient macedonians is RIDICULOUS and shows how little respect they have for their own ancestors.
2) Greek macedonians claiming that they are descendants of Alexander the Great (by the way he didn't have any offsprings!!!!) is equally absurd. However, they share with Alexander the same language and the same culture, i.e. they are all Greeks.
3) The Slavomacedonians can call themselves the way they want. Greece doesn't have to recognize them and doesn't have to accept them as allies. If somebody tomorrow says Alsace is not French and Bayern is not German can certainly say so, but France or Germany will not recognize a Republic of Alsace or a Republic of Bayern next to their borders.
4) It is irrelevant whether FYROM doesn't have the capacity to use military power to "liberate" Aegean macedonia. I am from Kozani, Greek Macedonian and don't want to be "liberated" by anyone. I feel happy being Greek, speaking the language of Aristotle and Alexander. The same is true for 2.5 million Greek Macedonians (23% of the Greek citizens).
5) It is fair to require from FYROM to accept a name that differentiates from Greek Macedonia. Call it Slavic, New, Northern, Upper, Central, Vardar or anything you like to put in front of the word Macedonia. This is generous enough...
6) There are a few slavomacedonians in Greece and they are free enough to have their own party called "Ouranio Toxo". They got 6000 votes in the 2004 elections for european parliament and they represent 0.05% of Greek citizens. They didn't bother participating in the last elections. They are also free enough to complain for a million things but they have to accept the laws that all Greek citizens accept.
These are obviously not intended to persuade people that have betrayed Aristotle's logic and insist blindly in their ignorance. But I hope will help open-minded people and FYROM has plenty of them.
King of Macedon asked out of his ignorance how do the Greek interpret the name “Makedonia”?
Makednos or Makedon, means "tall" or "highlander".
According to Hesiod, a 700 BC poet who predates Homer; Hellen (Ancient Greek: Ἕλλην, Héllēn) was the mythological patriarch of the Hellenes, the son of Deucalion (or sometimes Zeus) and Pyrrha, brother of Amphictyon and father of Aeolus, Xuthus, and Dorus.
Hellen is also another name for Greek, meaning a person of Greek descent or pertaining to Greek culture, and the source of the adjective "Hellenic". Each of his sons founded a primary tribe of Greece - Aeolus the Aeolians, Dorus the Dorians and Xuthus the Achaeans (from Xuthus's son Achaeus) and the Ionians (from Xuthus's probably illegitimate son Ionas ) together with his sister's Pandora's and Thyia's sons with Zeus and according to Hesiod's (probably) "Eoiae" (Greek : Ηοίαι (ancient Greek Ἠοῖαι from Ἠ' οἷαι = "or such women as") or "Catalogue of Women", Graecus the Graecians, Makednos the Makedones and Magnes the Magnetes .
They conquered Phthia and subsequently spread their rule to other parts. The people of those areas came to be called Hellenes, after the name of their ancestor.
Late in the fifth century BC a Greek historian, Hellanicus, who visited the court of Macedonia, made the father of Macedon not Zeus but Aeolus, a thing which he COULD NOT have done unless he knew that the Macedonians were speaking an Aeolic dialect of GREEK. A remarkable confirmation of their Greek speech comes from the Persians, who occupied Macedonia as part of their conquests in Europe c.510-480. According to Hellanicus Makednos was one of the 10 sons of Aeolus,who was son of Hellen and founder of the Aeolian Greek tribe.
Alexander the Great is the first commander who officially uses the terms Hellas and Panhellenic League (league of all Greek tribes except for the Lacedaemonians) when he declares the beginning of his military campaign against the Persian ruler of the Greek city-states of Asia Minor (Ionia) in order to take revenge on behalf of their ancestors.
We do have some examples of the Macedonian Greek dialect and it does not resemble Slavic in any way.
By the way, 'motherland' in Slavic is 'rodina' not 'macedonia'.
Tito is dead for a long time. I do hope the Western Bulgarians of Skopje wake up to reality one day. It is not all bad being a Slav.
VETO.....FOR NATO....AND EU AFTER A WHILE.....
Dear Greek fascists,
It is not enough that you have created a state on territories that were never Greek, and now you dont even let people feeel as teh prefer to feel ( is this real greek democracy)
The day will come when you will be asheme of what you did in modern history (the same as serbs are ashame of their history under slobodan milosevic).
But unlike You, Macedonians are cosmopolits , as was Alexander the Great, and will forgive You, because we want normal neighbourly relations.
May god help you and excuse your stupidity and frustrations.
Unfortunately Greece went too far, not only do they deny the right to the name, they also put in question the Macedonian identity itself. It is only because of years of non-good-neighborly relations politics, years of embargo, humiliation, denial that the Republic of Macedonia is now what it is - a country where nationalism and populism rise. Never would I have imagined that my fellow Macedonians would become as radical and irrational as our neighbors. Unfortunately every day I open the news fearing a new worsening of the situation. And as much as I try to balance things in my head, I must say that this time the Greeks are more to blame than anyone else. Greeks have done a enormous damage to Macedonia and SHOULD REPAIR IT hand in hand with the progressive forces in Macedonia. I know there are reasonable people left on both sides, do not let the "Macedonian question" repeat itself.
Macedonia has the right to its name and identity and it is only through constructive dialogue that we could find a way out, as long as human rights and principles are respected.
I must add that EU and NATO have their share of the burden and should address it instead of playing deaf and blind.
Do you want another Milosevic regime in the Balkans?
Then help Macedonians out of this hysterical situation.
Unlike all of our neighbors, we have never been nationalists and we won't let that happen!
It should be called TYROM instead. TYRI is Greek for cheese. I think it suits those little dillusional nobodies the best as farming is the best they do.
No, I think you Greeks should find your roots in Ethiopia.
Macedonia existed and still exists.
It`s an ancient country, and if you think you can change this name, you`re wrong.
Macedonians won`t let that happen.
PIRIN VARDARSKA and AEGEAN are MACEDONIA.
Stop with covering your real history assholes.
GREEKS... take it up the arse doo da doo da... GREEKS takeit up the arse.. doo da doo da....
Greece runs all that political bullshit... and brainwashes its people... who did that in recent history.. Saddam Hussain.. Should the yanks come and blow greece away... it doesnt matter...in history you couldn't take back Macedonian land... so in modern times... you use politcal bullshit to try and deny a persons right to their country.. Napret Makedonjia...
P.S - you greeks were all a bunch of loosers when Alexander came around looking for dunb cunts to get slaughtered in the front line... so he rounded up tribes of greek dodo's... and used them as body shields... and in return to pay their repsect you Greeks taught Alexander the Great Macedonian... ( NOT GREEK ) how to take it up the ass... doo da doo da.. Greeks take it up the ass doo da doo da... Come along now you greek boys.. sing along... Greeks take it up the ass.. doo da... you know it has a great ring to it... AT THE END OF THE DAY... SAY AND DO WHAT YOU GREEKS WANT... YOU WILL NEVER CLAIM MACEDONIA... ITS WHAT THE WESTERN WORLD CALL... WISHFUL THINKING... A shout for all Macedonians...Stefce ther Makedonce... PROUD AND LOUD MACEDONIAN... Napret Makedonija !!! Da te moo day te,da se na pieh... Stefce po saka da se na pi ye... GERCEISTE se duput vo gazo... pazete.. da na dish gerk... ye lesno.. placshi da yeh Makedones !!!
Hristo you moron, a child in Greece is not allowed to be christened with any name that is not considered Greek. This has been part of their state-sponsored Hellenization process since the birth of modern Greece in early 1800's.
MegasAlexandros the truth hurts does it not, you Greek Macedonians are so proud to be Macedonian after not even 100 years in Macedonia - you need to read up on your own history and the land to which you belong, Anatolia a.k.a Asia MInor, a.k.a Turkey.