Greece, Riots and John Lennon
I would like to clarify a point about recent events: As bullets can not be answer to words, likewise you can not honor someone’s memory with stones and Molotov.
As I see things...an ostracized bullet to Alexis’ chest, a straight one to Greek society’s heart: I am continually trying to understand riots motive but they refuse to talk. I approached them today with two friends having a camera but they insisted on turning off the camera. Actually there are no cameramen during their march. They do not want journalists among them because they believe journalists are alternating facts. I give them reason. But I would like also to know about their anger. I ask to see them in private but the answer was vague. Facing today’s march, I witnessed anger and rage against the policemen. They throw pieces of marbles and stones. They scream and yell. Their faces are covered. I want to understand them. Being a young nowadays do not mean at all being carefree and cool. I agree, but to start as a teenager with violence is very dangerous. During the protest a heard a passer-by say “How can you call yourself Greek when you try to put fire to the National Library, to the Archeological Museum, no matter the age.”
I would like also to clarify something about the recent events in Greece: They have NOTHING to do with the international economic crisis. On the contrary, as wisely pointed out by Nikos Xidakis in “Kathimerini” newspaper (9.12.08) as society “we just offer material, as much as we‘ve got, no matter what! This is all we got. We are spiritually and ethically orphans”. I can understand the youngsters. I am one of them! As society, as parents, as professors we do not encourage the pursuit of any calling in writing, music, dance, painting, any creative art, any spiritual advancement or any act that derives from our higher nature instead of our lower…and lower is violence. Alexis Grigoropoulos was unlucky but one could say that he was born lucky. He was coming from a wealthy family, schooled at one of the best private schools in Greece but somehow this was not enough for him. Unfortunately the same night before he was shot dead, he was reported as participating in violent events at a polo game.
I have lived abroad and teenagers and students do not enjoy all that goods from family as we do in Greece. They do not grow up with expectations from family, society and university to find them a job in the public sector as soon as they graduate, to live in the security of the public sector, buy them a car, pay for their vacations, in other words they live with less “acquis” than we do. We have been hypnotized from the cradle, we have been made to fear to dream, we have been made to fear to dare and we feel that deep in our soul. Because the last thing when you TRULY DARE in your life is a hood to cover your face. Then we protest for the wrong reasons, serving the political interests of others, charged with our education, in a way to prepare us to become exemplary employees and not to be free thinkers. “Carry their bag” until they have the generosity to treat us as equals. The only possible way for many –for those not exposed to intellectual art or culture- seems protest or vandalism of what they can not create. But vandalism and free thinking are mutually exclusive. It goes without saying that this principle applies to drugs, alcohol, shopping, depression, gossip, TV.
How can we make the world a better place? For me real revolution passes by decent hard work and when I say work I mean the active exercise of one’s faculties in conformity with virtue (Aristotle). John Lennon once wrote: Well, you think you‘re so clever And CLASSLESS and free But you‘re all fucking peasants As far as I can see



Comments
Elina... I am not a fan of violence and I don't think demonstrations are the best way to express a political will or frustration in a democratica society. However, despite the presence of leftists, I feel that what is happening in Greece is the first eurogeneration mass demonstration...
The feelings of many Greek young people, with little hope and opportunities for their lives, is something felt by so many other young people all around Europe. In Italy, the situation is not dramatically different and I fully understand the sense of frustration of so many Greeks in my age. They decided to demonstrate, I decided to "emigrate".
This is something completely different from the 68 movement, it is even a movement against many 68 leaders and ideas... what is even more stunning is that politicians are completely unable to answer to these demands at the EU and National level.
Nicola:
Of course, politicians are unable to answer . . . . They never answer: rubber truncheons do. Besides, what else have they to do? Aristotle and his boys did it all long ago!
P.S. Nicola:
If you're still wondering what happened with 68, consider my answer one day when, as one who was falsely considered to be some kind of guru or mathematical genius, I was asked what the number 68 meant to me. To this, I answered,
"68: It was a harvest year. That was the year they harvested Martin Luther King and Bobby Kennedy."
After the guffaws had died down, I got no more questions.
"They do not grow up with expectations from family, society and university to find them a job in the public sector as soon as they graduate, to live in the security of the public sector, buy them a car, pay for their vacations, in other words they live with less “acquis” than we do."
Wow, its seems that Greece is quite a paradise, if everybody gets so much from his family. Dont you show just one side of the picture?
Or is it that in greece people buy exagerated things just with loans? and that will get to an end because of the new economical "pragmatism"?
Fascinating discussion on an absurdly controversial issue. I personally condemn violence as a form of expression but I also have to admit that sometimes too much of inactivity can easily lead to that.
What I do not get is what people want. Not for tomorrow, but for the day after.
I remember our reportage/debate last year and I remember how people got surprised when I asked what role should university have in your country.
I agree that young people live in a quite strange way there - and I agree with Nicola, not so different from the way people lives in Italy - but, now that you managed to bring everyone down in the streets...now that you forced everyone to think a bit more about the direction of their country and their future...what happens now?
Do you - trust me, I am not being any provocative...I am just curious to know your opinion - do you think they will also be able to sit down and work hard looking for those answers your politicians have not been able to give in the past decades?
Giovanni, I remenber your investigation here every day..can you believe that? It has passed one year and a half and situation is still tended. One thing leads to the other and I think right now there is a general disappointment in Greece not only for universities but politicians in general. Unfortunately universities in Greece are the place who reflect political battles and ...students are not always aware about what they are fighting.
There is a nexus, a complex of "political" interests of professors, of Rectors, who speculate on the anger or the enthusiasm of young student. I have come to hate the actual meaning of the word "politic", in greek language it means the relatif with the city (POLI), the interest of the city. Today the word has totaly lost its meaning...
About your question: as far as i know until now they have not sat down and work hard..
I remain optimist..
Well...I would even really love to come back there and work a bit more but..unfortunately I will have to organize myself in some different ways...tho I really want to get back talking about it cause..you might be optimist (with dots), but I am definitely more skeptical..
Well...I would even really love to come back there and work a bit more but..unfortunately I will have to organize myself in some different ways...tho I really want to get back talking about it cause..you might be optimist (with dots), but I am definitely more skeptical..
In case that crisis gets worse among youngsters across Europe it would be a good idea to prepare something through cafebabel...lots of voices from lots of european countries, sounds interesting and european. Of course Greece is a little bit sui generis that is why i would love to see analysis from other Europeans
I am a 66 year old lecturer currently in the Highlands of Scotland, living in England and in Corfu and with a half-Greek family. I am interested in how things look to you so please keep thinking aloud on your blog - even though puzzled and confused - like most of us. I have been conversing on the web with quite a few people - Greek and non_Greek, Greek residents and diaspora Greeks. By all means surf through our shared thoughts on my blog:
http://democracystreet.blogspot.com...
We are back in Greece in a few weeks via Thessaloniki and Kalambaka
Herete. Simon